Vanilla
Macro of an open vanilla orchid bloom against a dark ground

The science

What a complete
vanilla actually is.

Vanilla is not experienced through aroma alone. Ten sensory descriptors, three products, one common scale - measured by GC-MS and HPLC, and published side by side.

The sensory signature

More than aroma

It is easy to talk about vanilla as an aroma, because aroma is the part that arrives first. But a vanilla pod delivers two things at once: volatile aroma compounds that give lift, top character and immediate recognition, and non-volatile constituents that give body, length, and the sweetness that keeps arriving after the aroma has gone.

Take the second half away and what remains is thin. It smells like vanilla and finishes like nothing. That is the practical difference between a vanillin isolate and a bean extract, and it is the reason a product reformulated down to vanillin alone is so often described by consumers as tasting cheaper without their being able to say why.

We call the whole of it the complete sensory signature of the bean - volatile aroma and the non-volatile constituents that carry body, length and sweetness together.

Cured vanilla pods split open showing dense seed
A split vanilla pod beside a bright amber pool of extract

The measurement

Ten descriptors.
One scale.
No hiding place.

Every profile on this page is scored on the same absolute scale, so the three products can be read against each other rather than each flattered in isolation. Where a descriptor is absent, the chart says so.

Descriptor by descriptor

Full Spectrum against the bean

The radar shows the shape. These bars show the distance - each descriptor with the bean extract behind and Full Spectrum in front.

Vanilla / Sweet matched
Balsamic / Rich matched
Creamy / Milky matched
Caramellic / Honeyed matched
Bready / Toasted −2.6
Nutty / Savoury −2.6
Spicy / Woody −1.7
Floral / Perfumery −7.5
Smoky / Phenolic −2.2
Fresh / Lively −7.1
  • Vanilla Bean Extract
  • NeoVanil™ Full Spectrum

The figures

Every value, published

Sensory descriptor intensities, 0 to 10, for three vanillas
Descriptor Bean Extract NeoVanil™ FS NeoVanil™ 95
Vanilla / Sweet9.99109.83
Balsamic / Rich9.99109.83
Creamy / Milky9.99109.83
Caramellic / Honeyed5.365.5—
Bready / Toasted8.616—
Nutty / Savoury8.616—
Spicy / Woody8.687—
Floral / Perfumery9.512—
Smoky / Phenolic8.666.5—
Fresh / Lively8.61.5—

Profiles measured by GC-MS and HPLC. Scale anchored so that 10 is the strongest intensity observed across the comparison set. An em dash marks a descriptor that was not measured for that product.

Cost, not dose

The advantage is the cost line

A common misreading is that a fermentation-led vanilla is used at a lower dose. It is not. All three products sit within half a percentage point of 3% vanillin, so at any given delivered ppm they dose within about fifteen per cent of each other. Swapping between them barely changes the recipe.

What changes is what that dose costs. Where the vanillin came from - pod or fermenter - is the whole of the difference, and it is a difference of roughly seventy per cent for Full Spectrum and ninety per cent for NeoVanil™ 95, on a cost index against a 20-fold bean extract.

Dosage by application

100Bean extractCost index reference: a 20-fold Madagascar bean extract.
30NeoVanil™ FSApproximately 70% below the reference, at the same dose.
7NeoVanil™ 95Approximately 93% below the reference, at the same dose.
3Products, one doseAll three sit near 3% vanillin, so they dose in the same range.
Molten chocolate curling in a bright ribbon NeoVanil The two grades,
and when to use each.
Inside NeoVanil